Don’t Forget Jerusalem

By: Esti Hess  |  November 15, 2026

By Esti Hess, Opinions Editor

“Where do your loyalties truly lie?” This question, posed to me this past summer by a religious Jew serving as a sergeant in the United States military, has tormented me, constantly replaying in my mind like a broken record. The question was rooted in the claim that most American Jews have, at best, dual loyalty – and on average single loyalty – to the State of Israel, and not the United States of America. The sergeant claimed that this is the major failure of American Jewry; we ought to have our loyalty strictly to the country in which we live. 

The accusatory argument initially made me feel guilty for being an insufficient patriot. As someone who has been anything but silent about my plans to move to Israel after completing my studies, the conversation left me spiraling. But four months, one semi-quincentennial and two trips to Israel later, all of those circuitous thoughts culminated into one conclusive realization: the critique itself is inherently backwards. The very notion of the debate, the fact that I must even defend myself on this topic, is where the real failure of American Jewry lies – we have lost sight of our end goal.

I still do feel tremendous gratitude and appreciation towards America for what it’s done, not just for me, my family and the Jewish people, but for the West as a whole. I respect, and would like to protect, its original national mission. That being said, it would be heretical for me, or any American Jew, to believe that the United States as my place is the ultimate goal. 

“Where our loyalties lie” as Jews should not be dependent on a country at all, but rather on an omniscient Being and the system of laws and principles He set up for us, which includes the instruction to constantly hope for the geulah sheleima (complete redemption). To the greatest extent to which we can, we must try to hinge our every decision on what will allow us to abide by that framework. I believe Israel to be the best vehicle for me as an individual to do that, and for those who do not feel the same, it is nonetheless imperative that they view America the same way: as a means to the end of serving Hashem to the fullest.

And yet, it is a lot easier said than done. In America, so many of us have already fallen prey to the capitalistic quicksand, sucking us into a world where the purpose, the “why?” of existence, is to “make enough money to be comfortable.” 

Thank God, many among us have succeeded in achieving at least a basic level of this comfort. But for any faith-based individual, that shouldn’t be enough. There has to be a greater “why?” than comfort, and it should exist in the realm of a broader impact and in relation to morality and/or spirituality, with the aim of bringing the redemption in some way or another. Our biblical tenets from Tehillim and Kohelet remind us over and over again that an accumulation of wealth and honor in this world is useless, since we cannot take any of it with us to, or beyond, the grave. And yet, the ever-present cultural pressure overpowers that truth. While America is fundamentally centered around the values of liberalism and freedom of opportunity, being American has become defined by the extent to which one has exploited those values. Us feeding into that distinction means that American Jewry has lost its clarity of purpose.

On weekdays, before saying Birkat Hamazon (Grace After Meals), we recite Tehillim 137, lamenting our exile from the Land of Israel. We say, famously, “Im eshkachech Yerushalayim, tishkach yemini; tidbak leshoni lechiki im lo ezkirechi” (“if I forget thee, O Jerusalem, let my right hand forget [its cunning]. Let my tongue cleave to my palate if I cease to think of you, if I do not keep Jerusalem in memory even at my happiest hour”). These pasukim (verses) are also sung at weddings and found in art on the walls of almost every Jewish home – but their words are seldom heeded. 

Too often, the same American Jews who leave a corner in their house unpainted as a remembrance for the Beit Hamikdash are the Jews who look at their lives in the United States and think there is nothing left for them to aspire towards beyond owning a multi-story home in the tri-state area. They plan their lives in the years to come to include grandchildren and great-grandchildren living identical economic and geographical lives, and they forget to imagine, or at all hope for, the possibility of redemption. We are all guilty of forgetting that while America, due to its protection of inalienable rights and complex three-pronged democratic government, has been the optimal place for Jews in the past 2,000 years of exile, it is not the ideal. In envisioning a truly perfect future, one can, and should, imagine it to include a better America – but it should not include Jews living there.

So stand by the foundations of the great United States, and those dreams and desires which inspired the Founding Fathers to declare independence and draft a paradigm-shifting constitution and structure of governance. Continue to engage civically in this country. Be proudly patriotic in that way. But there is one red line you must draw for yourselves in thick ink, and that is refusal to succumb to the plight of the masses and lose sight of the true objective: doing your part to yearn for and bring the final redemption. 

My desire to make aliyah (move to Israel) is rooted in this very value of staying conscientious of the Jewish mission, and I will not be made to feel guilty about it. I will clarify, however, that the decision does not necessarily reflect a wider belief that I owe more or less allegiance to the modern State of Israel than I do to America; and even if it was, that would be the least of my shortcomings as an American Jew. I understand the multitude of reasons why the path I am choosing does not work for everyone, and I do not demand that anyone follow suit. I am not asking everyone to jump ship and move en masse to Israel. The one thing I will demand, however, is one simple task: wherever you are in the world, make sure to remember your “why.” No matter what you do, don’t forget Jerusalem.

Photo Credit: Unsplash