Some Are Guilty, All Are Responsible 

By: Shloimy Lowy  |  November 15, 2026

Shloimy Lowy, Photographer and Staff Writer

On October 20, 2024 at 1:42 AM, 57 men in a Snapchat group chat received a lewd message inviting them to take advantage of a drunk and high woman. What followed were multiple update messages, including “this is crazy work” and “shop still open?” – “yea.” Throughout the night, 7 men are alleged to have assaulted or raped Jane Doe, the anonymous woman in question, until she passed out at 5:45 AM. Much has been written about care versus consent, the legal loophole that complicates the case and whether Greek life on campus should be abolished. I am not here to adjudicate the case; whether all or only some of the seven are rapists we may find out in court. I would trust none of them around my daughter. And in the words of one of my rebbeim, “they are all going to Gehenom (hell).” 

That one can find four men willing to take advantage of a drugged woman is sadly not surprising. But what is scarier is that 57 members of a group chat saw that text and did nothing. Nobody protested the message. Nobody in that chat was courageous enough to object to the “free” advertisement of a human body up for grabs. And of course, nobody thought to report it to campus police, or at the very least to check that the woman was safe (One of the accused claims to have gone in there to check on her, but later posted on Snapchat that “the alumni sh* is not a bit. Firsthand pov not a bit,” complicating that narrative).

This leads me to my question: What are our responsibilities vis-a-vis the things our friends say on group chats? 

A couple months back, the Wilf in the Know group chat was overrun by spammy and sometimes racist, homophobic or misogynistic messages. The admins tried their best to block it, and kudos to them, removed some people at some point. In response, a new group chat was formed, called “Wilf Uncensored.” I joined that group chat to see what it was all about. 30 minutes later, I left. It was mostly hateful and toxic messages sprinkled with every slur – racial or otherwise – known to man, and absolutely nothing substantive. Back then I thought very little of it. Just guys having an edginess show-off contest. I didn’t want any part of it, so I left. Easy. But what happens when it isn’t as easy? 

In a morally clarifying opinion piece on the Cornell case, David French quotes C.S. Lewis in The Screwtape Letters: “Courage is not simply one of the virtues but the form of every virtue at the testing point, which means, at the point of highest reality.” Courage takes strength. It requires sacrifice of some sort. Sometimes, it requires a level of social ostracization. 

A couple months later, I made the mistake of checking X. I’ve read some of the most vile rhetoric there, including gross antisemitism and all the other phobias. However, these could all be defended with some version of “free speech, sunlight is the best disinfectant” etc. About a week after the Cornell news broke, I logged on to see what the people have been saying about it. I thought I might gain some insight about the difficult legal questions in the case, and sure enough, I would not have been surprised if some random guy said something horrible about the woman involved. 

What I found was much worse. I saw a community of men coming together to doxx Jane Doe and reveal her identity to the world. Without looking for it – this was on my For You page – I was being shown tweets (Xs) including photos, Instagram links, and other information about the woman these men alleged to be Jane Doe. Of course, these photos came along with vile comments about Jane Doe, comments with the general sentiment that she deserved what had happened to her, that the real victims were a boyfriend of hers and the men who allegedly assaulted her. In response, Jane Doe has had the police falsely called to her house and has received hateful messages to her personal phone. The New York Times later reported on this X movement.  

So I did what any rational being would do and deleted my X account. The site had fallen to a place of disgust even my freedom-of-speech brain could not handle. It was causing material harm. But over the next week, thinking about the real-world effects of casual and acute misogyny on group chats, I began noticing problematic behavior more and more, some of it from people I respect. In one group chat, people were typing out the letters of the n-word one message at a time. Later that week, someone posted about the Cornell case, in response to which a sticker was sent saying “stop rape, say yes.” I was unsure what the correct response was. 

In psychology class, we learned about a concept called pluralistic ignorance. Simply put, people mistakenly believe that their private beliefs or opinions differ from the majority within their social group. When one group member expresses an extreme viewpoint and nobody disagrees, we assume that everyone in the group believes it too. The group chat I am talking about has 24 people on it. 20 of them are decent people. None of them protest when messages like these are sent. The person who sent that sticker is a sweet, friendly guy, who in real life is incredibly respectful to women. 

On the one hand, many of these messages are never intended to be serious. Many are distasteful jokes, and perhaps protesting them only means that “you don’t get the joke.” On the other hand, if we get used to never protesting this rhetoric, we may never know when something is truly wrong. Additionally, what are the implications of allowing a culture where casual bigotry thrives? The people at the receiving end of that bigotry no longer feel comfortable being there. 

The inverse of pluralistic ignorance is the contagion of courage. If people mistakenly believe that everyone shares these extreme views, speaking out against it is one way to correct it. If you protest misogyny, that will show the group that no, not everyone holds the same views as the one loud guy. “Courage is contagious,” the controversial reverend Billy Graham once wrote. “When a brave man takes a stand, the spines of others are often stiffened.” The theory of pluralistic ignorance agrees.

During the civil rights movement, Rabbi Abraham Joshua Heschel remarked: “in a free society, some are guilty, all are responsible.” I think that might be a helpful way to think about our question. If you ignore a harmful message in a chat, you may not be guilty, but you sure are responsible. You are responsible for any harm that not protesting carries with it, and you are responsible for the culture it creates when nobody protests. In that group chat and in yours, only some may be guilty, but all are responsible. 

Rashi goes even further. In the story of Lot and Sodom, the Torah goes out of its way in emphasizing that the entire town, young and old, from all corners came knocking on Lot’s door to assault the messengers. Rashi sees this as proof that there was no righteous man in Sodom, for, in his words, not a single person protested. There may have been some who did not intend to rape, but all were guilty, for not a single person protested. 

In thinking this over, one rabbi told me that his personal bar would be at identifiable harm. “If there is an identifiable subject being harmed, as in the Cornell case, there is a moral obligation to act.” What he would consider harm would depend on the context. However, he acknowledged the limits of such a rule, especially when considering how group chats can foster a culture of misogyny where 57 men might do nothing about a text with clearly identifiable harm. 

Some of my non-Jewish friends tell me about casual antisemitism they encounter in their friend groups. They are unsure about how to respond to it. Is there an identifiable moral subject being harmed? Hard to say. Does it matter to you, a Jew, whether some dude in a bar in Indiana complains about the Jews? I’m not sure, but I’d sure feel better if the guy he complained to stood up for the Jews and protested anti-semitism. Would I consider it a moral obligation for him to protest? Probably not. But I would surely consider them courageous if they did.  

To do what is right is not always popular. It is difficult. It sometimes means that others may dislike you. They may think you are weak, or unfunny, or too woke, or just annoying. But not standing up for justice is the ultimate failure of your moral backbone. If nothing in your life challenges you morally, you are not moral, you are just swimming along. Without courage, morality is pointless. With courage, what remains is only to determine what is just and what is unjust. 

Somewhere along the lines of speech, comedy ends and injustice begins. Somewhere between a racist micro-aggression and a Snapchat group chat, the harmless becomes harmful, and a woman is violated. I remain unsure of where to draw the lines, but courage demands that we push the barriers, that we err on the side of doing good. Otherwise, we risk ignoring even the most blatant injustices. 

Photo Credit: Unsplash