By Gavi Tropper, Features Editor
Mamdani might not be too popular in our circles, but let’s give credit where credit is due.
On September 3, New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani announced a one-year moratorium on the use of artificial intelligence (AI) in NYC public schools. As of the start of this school year, no generative AI of any kind is to be used by students from kindergarten through eighth grade. High schoolers can still use AI, but only within certain approved programs.
“Children need teachers and human connection in order to learn and grow. They need to develop skills alongside their peers, build relationships with educators and wrestle with tough problems on their own,” Mamdani said in his announcement. “The tech industry wants us to believe that AI-powered early education is not only inevitable, but necessary. We do not see it that way.”
Any AI ban, of course, should raise immediate suspicion. AI is rapidly becoming a central part of our world and the future workplace. Keeping students from AI could prevent them from developing the knowledge and experience necessary to use the technology properly. Why, then, should students be forced to suffer through the kind of intellectual busywork that, in every other sector of society, is rapidly becoming obsolete?
The NYC policy even makes room for the possibility that AI may become an effective classroom tool. Right now, the total ban is only mandated for a single year. A number of pilot classes using different AI tools are being conducted this year to study how they impact students’ experience and development. Once data from this school year, as well as the results from the AI pilot programs, are collected and discussed, the city school board will draft a more permanent plan on how to incorporate AI into schooling.
Nonetheless, I would be surprised if AI proves very helpful in the classroom.
The underlying assumption that kids need to be taught to use the new technologies of their day is strange. Most of us take the opposite for granted; younger people tend to adapt to technology quicker than older generations. If anyone has to learn new tech, it’s the adults.
I remember in elementary school, we had classes where we were taught how to use PowerPoint: how to create a file, how to add text and how to add pictures off the internet. Within five minutes of playing around, most of us could figure out how to finish the assignment for the class; the only thing holding us back was the teacher’s pace. We’d be staring at the screens, waiting for the go-ahead to click on the text box or paste the line we’d copied. While the process of learning to properly use AI and computers wouldn’t look the same, most people seem to be using AI effectively today with little to no training. It’s not clear that there’s AI knowledge or skills for schools to teach that students wouldn’t find out anyway.
Really, the claim that students need to be introduced to new technologies in order to properly adapt to them should sound eerily familiar to trends in our own lifetimes. Back in the early 2010s, when personal technological devices like smartphones and laptops entered the mainstream, similar calls abounded to bring these devices into the classroom. The Obama administration, in 2010, released a plan to promote tech in schools, setting a goal that all schools would eventually provide individual devices for each student, regardless of their family’s financial means.
“Right now, many students’ learning experiences in school don’t match the reality outside of school,” Ann Darne, then Secretary of Education, said in a 2010 speech. “We need to bridge this gap.”
Over a decade later, with the administration’s goal largely achieved as 89% of schools now offer one-to-one devices, tech adoption isn’t exactly being celebrated. Research in the following years has revealed that one-to-one tech use in the classroom leads to a general decrease in student test scores – especially for younger children. Early on, there were fears of a wealth divide between wealthy kids with access to technology and poorer ones who didn’t. By the end of the decade, it became clear that the wealth gap had been reversed; poorer schools relied far more on technology in classrooms than wealthier ones.
With New York City’s new education policy, the issue is truly starting to come full circle; aside from the AI ban, this year’s new policy also included a ban on one-to-one screen time from kindergarten through second grade, and encouraged limits until eighth grade. It seems the goal is to retain some of the educational value of screens without allowing them to dominate the school day, as they currently do.
So, while there’s a lot to be learned from the tech adoption craze, one central lesson emerges: Just because a technology is being adopted across society doesn’t mean it will help in the classroom. After all, the goals of the workplace and the goals of the classroom are not the same. In the rest of the world, a technology that makes a process more efficient and requires less human input is a resounding success of innovation; in education, human effort and attention is the entire point.
Instead of focusing on what students can figure out on their own and adults would struggle to provide, schools should be focused on the sort of skills and knowledge adults are in a position to give: critical thinking and problem solving, a basic degree of worldly knowledge and a strong work ethic.
When education is viewed as the development of these basic skills, rather than mere practice for the “real world,” AI’s place in the classroom becomes far more questionable. AI has the capability to do everything students normally do: read texts, organize information, discern key points and apply the information to new situations and problems. When a student uses AI, what’s left for the student to do? AI is perfectly engineered to circumvent the kind of critical thinking and work ethic that school is meant to inculcate.
Obviously, there are much larger questions at play than merely education. The role of human thought and experience will have to be redefined more generally if they are no longer necessary for practical purposes. It’s worth noting, however, that this is all still theoretical; predictions of tech CEOs aside, the degree to which AI will actually be able to displace humans in the workforce won’t be known until after the fact. Until then, it would be prudent to keep on educating students with the mental muscles that have served us for thousands of years.
But even if down the road, AI could somehow render human thought in the workplace obsolete, it would be an absolute tragedy if human education went down with it. Besides the education-for-jobs mentality that dominates our modern discussion of schools, there’s another important line of thinking that education is important for its own sake. This idea is best expressed by the 18th-century thinker Jean Jaques Rousseau in Emile, his revolutionary work on education:
“It matters little to me whether my pupil is intended for the army, the church, or the law. Before his parents chose a calling for him, nature called him to be a man. Life is the trade I would teach him.”
In this view, education serves not only practical purposes, but the cultivation of the self; developing the mind is crucial for developing ourselves as people. This idealism, of course, came to take a backseat in the Western school system, and for obvious reasons – parents’ priority is their children being able to put food on the table, not lofty ideas of self-actualization. But in an age where humanity’s role in the workplace is rapidly diminishing, Rousseau’s ideas deserve a greater focus. If school is about education for “life” itself, then schools are just as relevant as ever. To neglect to develop thinking skills with the argument that AI can do them for us is to neglect our humanity.
At the very least, a lesson to take away from the personal device push is to approach change in education with more deliberation. The same way as a drug wouldn’t be released into the market without years of tests demonstrating its efficacy and safety, radical new tools shouldn’t be introduced to education without similar deliberation.
So, whereas public policy often comes across as “too little, too late,” the Mamdani administration seems to have done an effective job at crafting a policy that is strict enough to have a serious impact, while also leaving room for a more nuanced approach once more information is known. The one-year limit on the ban, with the intention to revisit the issue for the next school year, seems especially sensible. While I have my doubts, I wouldn’t be surprised if despite all the challenges associated with it, there will be some beneficial way of incorporating AI into education (at least, in certain controlled times and capacities).
A lot still remains to be discussed regarding other issues of AI in education, like AI use by teachers and textbook companies, which the new policy treats far more leniently than student use. But the Mamdani administration does deserve serious respect for having both the guts and perspective to craft a surprisingly thought-out policy for an extremely thorny issue. It could even stand as a model for our own Jewish schools as they confront these same issues.
Photo Credit: Unsplash